Advertising VS Public Relations…which is better? Now
there’s a loaded question! But is there an answer?
Readers; be the judge.
The Difference Between Advertising and PR
By Renée A. Prejean-Motanky
Many people don’t even know the difference between
advertising and public relations! I’m not even sure that
the difference is so clearly demarcated!
 |
|
Renee A. Prejean-Motanky
is a writer and strategic marketing and communications
management professional and consultant. Contact her
directly at RAPWrites@aol.com.
|
Perhaps one difference is that advertising makes it
possible to use a lot of "edgy", eye-dazzling techniques
to grab attention, while PR requires more subtlety…think
of advertising as the college-aged freshman. He’s a
party animal and he’s out to get attention. On the other
hand, PR isn’t "the life of the party" and hardly ever
stays out late. Advertising is so often "in your face"
and those of us that are interested are normally aware
of a company’s advertising campaigns, but how often are
we familiar with the associated public relations
activities?
Marketing focuses on products (or services), price,
promotion and place (distribution); collectively
referred to as the four "P’s". Public relations can be
applied to every part of the marketing mix, of which
advertising, the one the public are most familiar with
is, but one ingredient. Public relations should be to
the marketing practitioner, an integral part of the
marketing mix. Advertising is more likely to succeed
when prior public relations activity (also called market
education) has created knowledge and understanding of
the product or service being promoted. Public relations
is the discipline which looks after reputation, with the
aim of earning understanding and support and influencing
opinion and behavior. It is the planned and sustained
effort to establish and maintain goodwill and mutual
understanding between a business and its public(s).
But PR doesn’t stop there. The PR professional
becomes a jack-of-all-trades…writing press releases,
organizing news conferences and producing company
newsletters. Many of us also function as the liaison
between media and company while guiding internal
communications as well.
There’s an entire list of functions PR pros assume,
such as:
- Public speaking
- Being interviewed on radio/TV
- Attending conferences
- Exhibitions and trade shows
- Arranging press launches
- Organizing opening days or visits to plant and
premises
- Coordinating studio location photography
- Crisis communications
- Acting as the client’s spokesperson
- Providing training to the client to be his/her own
spokesperson
- Online PR
- Event management
- Research
- Evaluation
- Corporate identity
- Strategic planning
We’re like chameleons that adapt readily to any
situation that arises. PR professionals are a lot like
sponges. We absorb and learn everything possible about a
client’s business and then become multi-tasking experts,
handling several things at the same. Nothing can be
allowed to slip through the cracks because all of these
things can have an effect on the bottom line.
The Bottom Line
With today’s economic environment and continued
pressure on debt, cash flow and profitability, companies
need people who can make a measurable difference to the
bottom line. PR professionals can certainly help.
When businesses seek justification for how their
marketing dollar is spent public relations has an
advantage over advertising in several key areas:
Flexible strategies – a PR campaign is a
living, dynamic process and can be re-shaped in
mid-stream if necessary. Companies have more
flexibility to adjust and change the focus of their
messages over the course of a campaign.
Flexible resources – PR campaign resources can
be adjusted to meet the bottom line without disrupting
a campaign’s effectiveness. A public relations
consultant is well-versed in multiple elements, e.g.
strategy development, writing, media relations and
etc. But an advertising team might consist of
strategists, coy writers, designers and media
placement specialist. Removing or weakening any one
element results in a weakening of the overall
campaign.
Longer lifecycle – a properly executed PR
campaign not only brings short-term results, but
long-term relationships which yield benefits over
time. By comparison, the life cycle of advertising is
defined by placement schedules which inevitably show
diminished returns when extended.
Time to market – PR campaigns tend to have a
shorter turn-around time than advertising campaigns.
Communications professionals can re-use information
from one campaign to the next. More resources can be
devoted to initial strategy, cutting the overall
delivery time.
Advertising or Public Relations?
The most effective marketing strategy encompasses a
comprehensive plan that includes a communications mix of
marketing tools, that should include advertising and
public relations. The two work hand-in-hand to produce
desired results.
Today more savvy marketing professionals understand
this. Public relations can almost be regarded as a
bigger activity than advertising because it relates to
all the communications of the total organization,
whereas advertising, although it may cost more than
public relations, is mainly limited to the
marketing/sales function. It is wise business practice
for public relations to work with advertising, rather
than relying solely on advertising to break into a new
market or to introduce a new and unknown product or
service.
A number of new products have failed to sell simply
because there is no build-up or market education and
hence the advertising spend was a waste of money. Many
small-medium business people (and some in larger
corporations) think about marketing only in terms of
advertising. Yet there are other elements which can make
advertising more effective, or which in some situations
can save that part of the budget entirely.
Recent research for AT&T has confirmed—not only do
advertising and public relations each contribute
separate benefits, the two disciplines can be even more
effective if managed together. In fact, in periods of
lighter advertising, public relations can compensate by
supporting brand loyalty. Researchers concluded that
advertising and public relations activity each has its
own impact on consumers, and these impacts interact to
influence perceptions, attitudes and behavior.
More than anything else, an organization’s news
environment determines the impact of its advertising.
Advertising may not be used by an organization but every
organization is involved in public relations at some
level. Public Relations embraces everyone and
everything, whereas advertising is limited to selling
and buying tasks such as promoting goods and services,
buying supplies and recruiting staff. Public relations
has to do with the total communications of an
organization; it is therefore, more extensive and
comprehensive than advertising.
On occasions, public relations may use advertising,
which is why public relations is neither a form of
advertising or a PART of advertising, but a crucial tool
that cuts right across the marketing mix.